Let’s celebrate the fallen heroes of the “best TV shows” pantheon – those brilliant gems ripped from our screens just as they ignited our obsession. Dive into shows that deserved more seasons and remind yourself why some cancellations still leave scars.
The Best TV Shows Cancelled Way Too Soon
Better Off Ted (ABC, Two Seasons, 2009-10) The show revolves around Ted Crisp (Jay Harrington), the kind-hearted and ethical leader of the R&D department at Veridian Dynamics, a comically wicked company that prioritizes money over people. Despite great writing and acting, its dark and quirky humor did not translate into ratings.
Deadwood (HBO, Three Seasons, 2004-06) “Deadwood” is a TV series that challenges traditional notions of heroes and villains in the Wild West. It explores moral ambiguity and the human cost of ambition while being recognized for its high-quality production.Despite winning eight Emmy Awards and one Golden Globe, the show only ran for three seasons due to failed negotiations between HBO and creator David Milch.
Firefly (Fox, One Season, 2002-03) Firefly is a sci-fi series set in the year 2517. The Alliance, a powerful government, rules the star system, leaving the fringes wild and lawless. Serenity is a transport ship captained by Malcolm Reynolds and operated by his ragtag crew. Despite its popularity, the network canceled the show after one season. However, its passionate fan base led to a feature film called “Serenity” that wrapped up loose ends.
Freaks and Geeks (NBC, One Season, 1999-2000) Freaks and Geeks, which ran for only 18 episodes, is a cult classic that launched the careers of James Franco, Seth Rogen, Jason Segel, and Busy Philipps. The show’s realistic portrayal of adolescence, relatable characters, and sharp writing continue to resonate with audiences, making it a timeless favorite. Despite this, low ratings and bickering with NBC led to its cancellation after just 12 episodes.
Hannibal (NBC, Three Seasons, 2013-15) In this series set before “Silence of the Lambs”, a troubled FBI profiler named Will Graham partners with Dr. Hannibal Lecter, a renowned psychiatrist with a dark secret, to investigate a series of gruesome murders in 2013.
CHECK OUT ALL OUR GREAT PODCASTS… CLICK AN IMAGE TO GET STARTED!
And Some More…
Happy Endings (ABC, Three Seasons, 2011-20) “Happy Endings” is a sitcom about six friends in Chicago navigating adulthood after the break-up of the “perfect couple” of the group, Alex and Dave. Despite its cult following, the network canceled the show early due to erratic scheduling and low ratings.
Pushing Daisies (ABC, Two Seasons, 2007-09) The show follows Ned, a pie-maker who can bring the dead back for 60 seconds by touching them. He partners with his waitress Olive and investigator Emerson Cod to solve murders by briefly reviving the victims and questioning them about their demise.
Rome (HBO, Two Seasons, 2005/2007) The show depicts the lives of two Roman soldiers, Lucius Vorenus and Titus Pullo, during the first century BC. Political turmoil, military campaigns, and social upheavals marked this period. The show offers a grounded perspective on major historical events such as Caesar’s rise and fall, the Battle of Pharsalus, and the rise of Octavian.
A combination of high costs, declining viewership, and contractual limitations forced HBO to cancel “Rome” after the second season.
The OA (Netflix, Two Seasons, 2016-19) The story is about Prairie Johnson, a young woman who returns home after being gone for seven years. She’s now in her twenties, can see again despite being blind before, and has mysterious abilities. She calls herself “the OA” and won’t reveal where she’s been or what happened to her.
High school students gather around Prairie, intrigued by her story of a near-death experience, angels, and a dimension-hopping mission called “The OA.” As she unravels her tale, the students confront the boundaries between reality and perception.
Netflix never explained the reasons for the cancellation, citing a “mutual decision” and a desire to invest in new stories. This lack of transparency caused frustration among fans.
And the Original “Canceled Way Too Soon” TV Series…
Star Trek (NBC, Three Seasons, 1966-69) This iconic show follows the voyages of the starship USS Enterprise, captained by the bold and adventurous James T. Kirk. Alongside his crew, including the Vulcan officer Spock, the doctor Leonard McCoy, communications officer Uhura, and engineer Montgomery Scott, they boldly go where no man has gone before.
Technically the show was “ended,” not cancelled. Despite its end, “Star Trek” gained a massive cult following in syndication and became a cultural phenomenon, paving the way for the numerous spin-offs, books, animations, and feature films that continue to this day.